PFMConnect Blog

Improving public financial management globally

MENUMENU
  • Home
  • About
  • Key posts
  • Book reviews
    • Book review Posts
  • Corruption and PFM
    • Africa anti-corruption agencies' digital media
      • Africa ant-corruption agencies digital media posts
    • Corruption board
    • Corruption and PFM posts
  • Country profiles
    • Anguilla
      • Anguilla Posts
    • Antigua & Barbuda
      • Antigua & Barbuda Posts
    • Armenia
      • Armenia Posts
    • Azerbaijan
      • Azerbaijan Posts
    • Belarus
      • Belarus Posts
    • Belize
      • Belize Posts
    • Bosnia & Herzegovina
      • Bosnia & Herzegovina Posts
    • Burkina Faso
      • Burkina Faso Posts
    • Cook Islands
      • Cook Islands Posts
    • Ghana
      • Ghana Posts
    • Greenland
      • Greenland Posts
    • Guinea-Bissau
      • Guinea-Bissau Posts
    • Kyrgyzstan
      • Kyrgyzstan Posts
    • Macedonia
      • Macedonia Posts
    • Madagascar
      • Madagascar Posts
    • Mauritania
      • Mauritania Posts
    • Mongolia
      • Mongolia Posts
    • Nepal
      • Nepal Posts
    • Papua New Guinea
      • Papua New Guinea Posts
    • Republic of Congo
      • Republic of Congo Posts
    • Samoa
      • Samoa Posts
    • The Gambia
      • The Gambia Posts
    • Timor-Leste
      • Timor-Leste Posts
    • United Kingdom
      • United Kingdom Posts
  • Digital government
    • Africa PFM digital transparency posts
      • Country PFM digital transparency studies
      • Regional PFM digital transparency studies
    • Digital government posts
    • SIDS PFM digital transparency posts
      • SIDS country PFM digital transparency posts
      • SIDS regional PFM digital transparency posts
  • Fiscal transparency 2023
    • Central Africa
  • Local government
    • Brexit posts
    • Local government posts
  • Small island developing states
    • Small islands developing states posts
      • IMF Article IV reports SIDS countries A to C
      • IMF Article IV reports SIDS countries D to H
      • IMF Article IV reports SIDS countries J to P
      • IMF Article IV reports SIDS countries S
      • IMF Article IV reports SIDS countries T to V
    • Small island developing states board
  • State-owned enterprises
    • State-owned enterprises posts
    • State-owned enterprises board
  • Other topics
    • Aid effectiveness
    • Budgeting
      • Asset management
      • Climate change
      • Service delivery
    • E-governance
    • PEFA methodology
      • PEFA methodology posts
    • Procurement
      • Procurement posts
      • Procurement board
    • Property tax board
    • Public-private-partnerships
      • Public-private-partnerships posts
      • Public-private-partnerships board
    • Revenue
    • SDGs
      • SDG Posts
    • Social media
      • Social media posts
  • Contact us
  • Useful resources
  • Videos

Talking about the future

john.leonardo@pfmconnect.comJuly 21, 2023July 21, 2023 Brexit posts, Local government
image_pdfimage_print

Rishi Sunak

by David Fellows

This commentary suggests that the UK Government’s new Prime Minister, Rishi Sunak, should use this pre-election year to pursue a much-needed process of public engagement embracing honest analysis, realistic objectives and meaningful initial progress focused resolutely on the key issues.

Politicians can spend too much time stabbing at simple solutions to complex problems. This typifies the Opposition’s current behaviour resulting in frequent policy reversals or ‘clarifications’ but they are not alone. PM Sunak has just announced a substantial increase in medical training throughput but has given little analysis of current difficulties demonstrating how this single initiative will make a critical difference to the NHS.

A risky but more beneficial strategy would be to explain how he truly sees the UK’s key problems and opportunities, explaining their origins and his commitment to beneficial change within a realistic timescale. He would be open to engagement on refinement and priorities but he would emphasise his intention to move forward at speed within the limited time at his disposal before the general election. This would demonstrate intent, practicality and, wherever possible, some evidence of initial impact. The latter prospect is particularly valuable as it is an option that is only available to Government. It is conceded that such an approach would be highly demanding and allow some admission of past policy deficiencies.

The benefits would be three-fold. Firstly, Sunak has had limited opportunity to develop a rapport with the country and this would be an arresting start. Secondly, it would employ his key strengths of analysis, practicality, honesty in debate, ability to communicate in depth and he would be seen to credit ordinary people with the intelligence to understand hard issues. Thirdly, the Opposition would be challenged to meet him on his own terms or be seen as shallow and incapable of the grip required to make serious improvements.

Sunak is sufficiently different from both his two immediate predecessors that this more open, practical and carefully reasoned approach could signal the arrival of a new Government capable of making a critical difference at speed. Ideally, he would be joined by a small team of ministers that would share this style of presentation and help develop the thinking on the issues to be presented in this way. A more collegiate style would also signal a welcome robustness of relationships within Government.

I have already set out my views on the key issues: economic growth  (with the Government more ready to accept a pivotal role in levelling-up); green energy; housing and families; the structure, character and management of the civil service; and NHS reform. I accept that I must add immigration in its various forms. But mission creep must be avoided. This must not become the manifesto. It should be far more focused on the things that matter most.

When explaining why we are where we are and what we now need to do to deliver future success it is essential that the context is properly explained to the electorate. To me this breaks down as follows:

  1. The need to foster improved economic productivity and growth through innovation, leadership, education and training, leading to good job opportunities, self-sustaining communities in all regions and affordable public services. This includes addressing the UK’s current dependency on immigration to provide the necessary additional labour to compensate for the failure to produce sufficient home-grown talent or achieve adequate productivity improvements throughout the economy.
  2. The need to reign-in public spending and restore the public-private sector balance of the economy through greater public service efficiency and a much-reduced dependency on regulation. A key requirement of the latter being the creation of clear distinctions between public and personal responsibilities, a challenging task.
  3. The relationship between housing availability, family prosperity, general living conditions, birthrate and public service provision.
  4. The need to supplement renewable energy with carbon-based fuels for sufficient time to allow for the discovery and development of viable zero-carbon solutions that current technology is at present unable to provide on an industrial scale. This includes revisiting issues provisionally resolved by bogus zero-carbon solutions. Clearly current carbon emission deadlines must therefore be extended to avoid the economic and social disasters that will otherwise arise from current timescales.
  5. The need to identify the extent of NHS failings has already been referred to. In doing this, the dual public-private system that is already an integral part of UK health service provision must be officially acknowledged and developed in a coherent and cost-effective manner.
  6. The need to review the nature of the civil service given the dependency of Government on trust between elected and appointed officials. Specifically, to consider the continued validity of the expectation that senior officials will remain personally loyal to all ministers they serve, will advise them dispassionately and will be prepared to action the policies that are then determined by successive politicians. A change of party is the most obvious but not the only issue here.

These complex situations affect highly relevant issues requiring an elevated level of explanation and engagement. Sunak is equipped to rise to these demands.

The core narrative of the next Government could be introduced and developed in some depth from now onwards. The proposed approach carries the promise of a more profound relationship between Government and Country, rejecting hollow sound bites as a route to electoral success.

The five priorities may have been a starting point but the country needs a more substantial vision that does justice to the challenges that lie ahead.

David Fellows worked extensively in UK local government, was a leader in the use of digital communication in UK public service and became President of the Society of Municipal Treasurers. He was subsequently an advisor on local government reform in the UK Cabinet Office and an international advisor to the South African National Treasury. He is a director of PFMConnect, a public financial management consultancy, and a regular commentator on public financial management issues at home and abroad.

civil service, economic growth, families, general election, green energy, housing, immigration, levelling up, NHS, PM, productivity, public engagement, Rishi Sunak, UK government
  • ← SIDS’ economic outlook forecasts July 2023 update
  • Central Africa Fiscal Transparency 2023 →

Social

Follow us on: Slideshare

Recent Posts

  • The road to improvement: governance indicators and socio-economic outcomes                    May 11, 2024
  • SIDS’ economic outlook forecasts January 2024 update January 4, 2024
  • An open letter to the PM as he crafts his general election agenda September 18, 2023
  • Central Africa Fiscal Transparency 2023 August 16, 2023
  • Talking about the future July 21, 2023

Recent Comments

  • IMF Article IV reports SIDS T-V on Understanding Small Island Developing States’ economic challenge
  • IMF Article IV reports SIDS countries S on Understanding Small Island Developing States’ economic challenge
  • IMF Article IV reports SIDS countries J-P - PFMConnect Blog on Understanding Small Island Developing States’ economic challenge
  • IMF Article IV reports Countries D-H on Understanding Small Island Developing States’ economic challenge
  • IMF Article IV reports SIDS countries A to C on Understanding Small Island Developing States’ economic challenge

Categories

  • Africa anti-corruption agencies' digital media posts
  • Africa PFM digital transparency posts
  • Aid effectiveness
  • Anguilla Posts
  • Antigua & Barbuda Posts
  • Armenia Posts
  • Azerbaijan Posts
  • Belarus Posts
  • Belize Posts
  • Book review Posts
  • Bosnia & Herzegovina Posts
  • Brexit posts
  • Budgeting
  • Burkina Faso Posts
  • Central Africa
  • Cook Islands Posts
  • Corruption
  • Corruption and PFM
  • Corruption and PFM Posts
  • Corruption Board
  • Country PFM digital transparency studies
  • Digital government posts
  • Ghana Posts
  • Greenland Posts
  • Guinea-Bissau Posts
  • Kyrgyzstan Posts
  • Local government
  • Local government posts
  • Macedonia Posts
  • Madagascar Posts
  • Mauritania Posts
  • Mongolia Posts
  • Nepal Posts
  • Papua New Guinea Posts
  • PEFA methodology Posts
  • Procurement
  • Procurement Board
  • Procurement Posts
  • Property tax Board
  • Public private partnership Posts
  • Public private partnerships Board
  • Republic of Congo Posts
  • Revenue
  • Samoa Posts
  • SDG posts
  • SIDS countries A to C posts
  • SIDS countries D to H posts
  • SIDS countries J to P posts
  • SIDS countries S posts
  • SIDS countries T to V posts
  • SIDS IMF Article IV reports
  • SIDS PFM digital transparency posts
  • SIDS regional PFM transparency posts
  • Small Island Developing States
  • Small Island Developing States posts
  • Social media Posts
  • State-owned enterprise posts
  • State-owned enterprises Board
  • The Gambia Posts
  • Timor-Leste Posts
  • Uncategorized
  • United Kingdom posts
  • Useful resources
  • Videos

Archives

  • May 2024
  • January 2024
  • September 2023
  • August 2023
  • July 2023
  • February 2023
  • January 2023
  • November 2022
  • October 2022
  • August 2022
  • June 2022
  • May 2022
  • April 2022
  • February 2022
  • September 2021
  • July 2021
  • June 2021
  • April 2021
  • January 2021
  • December 2020
  • November 2020
  • October 2020
  • September 2020
  • August 2020
  • July 2020
  • May 2020
  • March 2020
  • October 2019
  • September 2019
  • August 2019
  • March 2019
  • February 2019
  • September 2018
  • July 2018
  • March 2018
  • February 2018
  • December 2017
  • October 2017
  • August 2017
  • July 2017
  • May 2017
  • February 2017
  • December 2016
  • July 2016
  • June 2016
  • May 2016
  • April 2016
  • March 2016
  • February 2016
  • January 2016
  • December 2015
  • November 2015
  • October 2015
  • September 2015
May 2025
M T W T F S S
 1234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
262728293031  
« May    

Email

Contact us at: team@pfmconnect.com

Copyright © 2025 PFMConnect Blog. Theme by Colorlib Powered by WordPress