African Finance Ministries, Social Media and Public Financial Management

African Finance Ministries, Social Media and PFM

Posted by David Fellows and John Leonardo[1]

What contribution does the Social Media have to make to improving public financial management (PFM) and fiscal transparency? In a recent study, we found that 26 of the 34 OECD states had Twitter sites and 18 had a Facebook presence.[2] Further work on African countries revealed that 11 finance ministries have active Facebook accounts (Angola, Egypt, Ethiopia, Ghana, Liberia, Rwanda, Senegal, Somalia, South Africa, Uganda and Zambia) with four of these using Twitter on a regular basis (see table below). The number of African Facebook accounts stood at 51.6 million as at 31st December 2012 and more than doubled to 120 million by 30 June 2015. Nigeria, South Africa and Kenya accounted for a quarter of this total but other African countries have been gaining ground.Mobile-phones-driving-user-growth-in-africa There appears to be a moderate correlation between internet use and per capita GDP for the group (excluding Somalia).

 

Country Proportion of Population using Internet (%) Facebook Users as Proportion of Internet Users (%) Twitter UN’s Human Development Index
Angola 23 15 0.53
Egypt 55 25 T 0.68
Ethiopia 2 47 0.44
Ghana 20 31 Ti 0.57
Liberia 5 0.41
Rwanda 9 18 T 0.51
Senegal 23 21 T 0.51
Somalia 2 79 unknown
South Africa 49 26 T 0.66
Uganda 22 7 0.48
Zambia 18 12 0.56

T = Finance Ministry makes regular use of Twitter

Ti = Ghana’s Finance Minister has a personal Twitter account

 

A large number of Facebook postings in these countries has an economic or financial content. For instance, Zambia’s Minister of Finance emphasises the importance of female employment, advocates the need for greater diversification into agriculture, manufacturing and non-extractive industries, and quotes a World Bank report on the need for major companies to support the development of small businesses. The Angolan finance ministry explains how falling oil prices have put pressure on public spending causing fuel subsidies to be reduced to maintain vital services, and stresses the importance of the linkage between economic stability, rating agency assessments and debt funding. Most countries provide details of budget spending proposals.

Postings were largely silent on service delivery commitments, service delivery standards, budgetary control experience, efficiency measures, cost reduction initiatives, procurement process development, anti-corruption activities and audit findings. Economic strategies remained largely unexplained and public questions and comments remained unanswered.

Few opportunities were taken to use the medium for broadening the reach of public service employment or the pool of public works contractors (eg inviting women to apply for jobs and bid for contracts). Citizens were not invited to complain about public service delivery or report corrupt or unfair practices.

Social Media is highly image-related and most postings were accompanied by photographs but too many were of men in suits, headings lacked clarity and explanation was often in short supply. Accompanying text was usually taken verbatim from ministerial speeches. Some sites were too dependent for their message on web links that referenced complex reports and these could not always be accessed via mobile reception. This could not, for the most part, be regarded as user friendly.

Some finance ministries are becoming quite adventurous in their postings. Zambia, Uganda and Liberia refer to prosecutions for tax fraud and corruption and this news was well received by the public. Liberia refers to its Open Budget Initiative and encourages the public to access budget material online. Angola, Liberia and Zambia refer to their PFM reform intentions. South Africa requests ideas for budget preparation. Angola refers specifically to its intentions to improve tax collection and procurement practices. Egypt makes regular announcements about training courses, and is also a regular user of video clips.

Several countries receive a regular flow of public comments, ranging from appreciative to openly hostile. Zambia demonstrates a lively interaction. Its citizens clearly have the confidence to express both appreciation and scepticism depending on the context. Its site is varied in subject matter, photographs are often interesting and the postings are regularly updated. Not surprisingly it also has the most likes.

What applies to Facebook also applies to Twitter but with greater emphasis. With the limitation on characters links to official sites were simply overused. The personal account of Ghana’s Finance Minister was perhaps the most engaging. YouTube has specific explicatory uses but we feel it has not been shown to have general applicability.

Social Media is a hard task master. At best, it requires strong images and short explanations. Laborious text pieced together from formal speeches or official documents is not an ideal format. Further reading can be offered but should not be used to carry the initial message if the intention is to engage the casual browser. Attention must be won.

At present, finance ministry website visits originating from Social Media are very limited (Egypt at 11% being the highest but for most websites the traffic is negligible). On the other hand, given the rapid growth in Social Media use, particularly Facebook, there is huge potential for using this communication channel as a gateway to website-based information and online service delivery.

Governments can prepare for this by developing Social Media strategies as exemplified by Uganda’s guidelines.

Politicians in some countries have begun to fear Social Media for its capacity to spread discontent and inflame communities. So why should finance ministers choose to use Social Media? Perhaps because it is one of the few ways that politicians can hope to reach the younger generation in significant numbers at a time when the general level of confidence in government appears to be low and decreasing. The OECD study referred to earlier found that only 40% of adults in OECD countries expressed trust in their governments. Should we expect the experience in developing countries to be different?

The same OECD study found that 30% of young people in Holland used Social Media to discuss politics and civic issues. This was the highest ratio of any country but it does suggest that Social Media is already a relevant political vehicle. If they choose to grasp this opportunity, finance ministers may find they can use Social Media to increase public understanding of public finance and budgeting, expand the opportunities for engaging the private sector in business partnerships with the government, and even improve the willingness to pay taxes.

If this is a reasonable supposition then perhaps development partners and even private sector investors will begin to take an interest in the potential relevance of Social Media.

 

Postscript

Just after this blog was published Facebook has announced a satellite system to extend its reach into areas of sub-Saharan Africa that were not previously served by the internet. Facebook plans satellite to boost sub-Saharan Africa internet. This makes the case for the use of Facebook, in particular, as an important medium of public service communication in Africa and reinforces the relevance of social media to the PFM agenda.

 

[1] The authors are Principals of PFMConnect. They have been engaged on projects in Africa, Asia and the Pacific funded by the World Bank, EU, ADB and DfID.

 

[2] OECD Working Paper on Public Governance, No. 26 “Social Media Use by Government”.OECD Working Paper on Public Governance No. 26

abridged version of this blog is available at http://blog-pfm.imf.org/pfmblog/2015/10/finance-ministries-social-media-and-pfm.html#morefinance-ministries-social-media-and-pfm

18 thoughts on “African Finance Ministries, Social Media and Public Financial Management

  1. Daud Mohamud adan

    Masha Alllaah ! waa horumar weyn aad ayaan ugu faraxsanahay runtii waxaan aaminsanahay in aan Dowlada badan ka hormari karno haddaan helno Madax daacad u ah dadkooda , dalkooda iyo diintooda Allaahna waxaan kabaryayaa in uu madaxdeenna fahamsiiyo Xaqa iyo Caddaaladda ayna noqdaan kuwa u damqa dadkooda dhibaataysan
    kana shaqeeya danta guud ayagoo wax walba ka hormarinaaya Maslaxadda Ummadda MAHADSANIDIIN !!

  2. Abdullahi Dahir

    Also ministry of finance of southwest state of somalia uses PFM and new ataff was trianed in nairobi last month for implementing this new system for public financial management

  3. finance-courses.com

    We are a gaggle of volunteers and starting a brand new scheme in our community.
    Your site offered us with useful information to work on. You have done an impressive
    task and our whole neighborhood shall be thankful to you.
    finance-courses.com like best example!

    1. john.leonardo@pfmconnect.com Post author

      Thank you for your comments.

      You may be interested in the PEFA reports that we have recently placed on our PFMConnect website.

      Kind regards

      John Leonardo

  4. google plus adwords

    Good day! This is my first comment here so I just wanted to give a
    quick shout out and tell you I genuinely enjoy reading your blog
    posts. Can you recommend any other blogs/websites/forums that cover the same topics?

    Thanks for your time!

  5. g mail log in google accounts gmail account

    First off I want to say terrific blog! I had a quick question which I’d like to ask if you don’t mind.
    I was curious to find out how you center yourself and clear your mind prior to writing.
    I’ve had difficulty clearing my mind in getting my ideas out there.
    I truly do take pleasure in writing but it just seems like the first
    10 to 15 minutes are usually wasted just trying to figure out how to begin.
    Any suggestions or tips? Appreciate it!

    1. john.leonardo@pfmconnect.com Post author

      Thank you for your comments.

      Our approach has been to identify the topic we are interested in, do the analysis and determine our findings. This makes it easier to write. I hope these remarks help.

      Kind regards

      John Leonardo

  6. externalizare it

    Hello there I am so thrilled I found your site, I really fund you
    by error,while I was searching on Aol forr something else,
    Regardless I amm here now and would just like too say thank you for a incredible
    powt and a all round exciting blog (I also love the theme/design), I don’t have time too look over it all at the moment but
    I have saved it and also added your RSS feeds, soo when I have time I will
    be back to read a great dewal more, Please do keep
    up the fantastic jo.

    1. john.leonardo@pfmconnect.com Post author

      Hi

      We may have interest.

      Please forward your proposal.

      Thanks.

      Kind regards

      PFMConnect

    1. john.leonardo@pfmconnect.com Post author

      Thanks for your interest.

      Please complete the form on our blog.

      Kind regards

      John Leonardo